How many hours a week does your HR team lose to manual work? Find out in a free survey (in Polish) →START >>>

GuideHR processes

A business case for an HR platform: how to calculate the cost of the current state and the return on implementation

A business case for an HR platform: how to calculate the cost of the current state and the return on implementation

HR platform proposals rarely lose on merit. They lose at the stage where they have to be compared with other projects competing for the same budget –⁠ and the only value the proposal offers is “a better employee experience”.

This is not HR’s fault. The benefits of streamlining employee processes are spread across the whole organisation and several cost lines, so they are harder to pull together into a single number than in the case of a production machine or a warehouse system. But harder does not mean impossible.

Below you will find:

  • four categories of cost that the organisation already bears, methods for calculating them on your own data, the CFO, COO and CHRO perspectives, and
  • a way of designing the implementation so that its impact can be demonstrated after a year.

Why the HR argument does not get through the investment committee

From the perspective of the person deciding on capital allocation, a proposal based on engagement has three weak points.

  1. First, it describes a desired state, not a difference. The committee needs to know what will change compared with today –⁠ not how good things will be.
  2. Second, it has no counter-scenario. Every investment project is compared with the “do nothing” option. If the proposal does not show how much doing nothing costs, the zero option wins by default, because it looks free.
  3. Third, it does not indicate when the impact will become measurable, nor the metric on which it will be measured.

Reframing is simple, although it requires working with data: instead of arguing for the benefit of implementation, calculate the cost of the current state. That cost is already in the P&L –⁠ it is just spread across lines where nobody adds it up.

Four categories of cost the organisation already bears

1. The cost of maintaining a fragmented tool stack

An organisation without a coherent platform usually pays for several solutions: an intranet, a flexible benefits (cafeteria) platform, a survey tool and sometimes a separate document workflow system. The visible part is the licences. The invisible, and usually larger, part is:

  • administrators’ time spent maintaining several user databases,
  • separate contracts, invoices and data processing agreements to renew and audit,
  • every new hire and every leaver multiplied by the number of systems,
  • user support spread across several channels.

How to calculate it: add up the annual licence costs of all HR tools, add the estimated administrative time (number of systems × hours per month × hourly rate) and the cost of contract handling on the legal and procurement side. The result is the reference point for comparison with a platform that consolidates these functions –⁠ with Worksmile it is worth comparing module by module, because the organisation pays only for the areas it actually replaces.

2. The cost of administrative work in HR

This is usually the largest and least visible line, because it is not an external cost –⁠ it is the opportunity cost of the headcount you already have.

How to calculate it: choose the five most frequent repetitive tasks (answering questions about leave balances, retyping requests from email, preparing documents from templates, collecting confirmations that documents have been read, compiling payroll data). Measure their actual time over two weeks –⁠ a simple tally spreadsheet is enough. Multiply the result by the cost of an FTE.

This number is usually surprising, regardless of the size of the organisation. It is worth calculating even if the decision to implement is not made –⁠ because it shows how much of the HR department’s expert capacity is taken up by retyping data.

It is also worth estimating separately the tasks that do not need to reach HR at all. In Worksmile, questions about balances and procedures are handled by the Knowledge Base with an AI Assistant, while requests and documents are handled by modules in which employees and managers act on their own. This is usually the largest single item in the calculation.

3. The cost of turnover and ineffective onboarding

The cost of replacing an employee includes recruitment, the manager’s time, reduced productivity during the onboarding period and the knowledge that leaves with the person. The impact of good onboarding on early turnover is measurable in organisations, although the size of the effect depends on the industry and workforce structure –⁠ which is why it is worth calculating on your own data rather than on someone else’s benchmarks.

How to calculate it: establish your own cost of replacing an employee in key roles, then check the percentage of leavers in the first 12 months. The product of these two values is the amount directly influenced by the quality of onboarding. Even a cautious assumption about reducing it gives a figure comparable with the cost of the system.

4. The cost of risk and unclosed processes

This category does not generate a cost every month –⁠ it generates an exposure that materialises rarely, but expensively.

  • No evidence that an employee has read a document in force. An active account of a former employee in a system to which nobody revoked their access.
  • Unreturned equipment.
  • Personal data processed in a tool that was not covered by a review.

Each of these events has a common cause: the lack of a single place where the process has a status and an owner. In Worksmile, this is closed by the compliance and policy management and work tools register modules, as well as scenarios triggered when someone joins or leaves –⁠ together with audit logs and role-based access control.

How to calculate it: estimating expected value (probability × cost of the event) is not very reliable in this area. A qualitative approach is more effective: list the events the organisation cannot document today and ask the legal department which of them would be a problem during an inspection or a dispute. For the CFO, this is usually a stronger argument than a calculation based on probabilities plucked out of thin air.

Three perspectives on the board, three different metrics

Implementing an HR platform touches the areas of responsibility of several board members, and each of them sees it differently. A proposal that speaks with one voice convinces one person.

Perspective Key question Metric to show Where to get the data after implementation
CFO Does it lower costs and bring exposure under control? Total cost of HR tools, administrative cost in FTEs, utilisation of benefit budgets vs. their size Reports on budget and benefit utilisation, licence comparison before and after
COO Does it shorten processes and remove bottlenecks? Request turnaround time, time to prepare a workstation for a new hire, number of manual steps Process statuses in the requests and cases module, HR reports
CHRO Does it free up the team and improve retention? Share of HR time spent on repetitive tasks, first-year turnover, communication reach HR analytics and reports, communication read data, pulse check results

The practical consequence: before implementation you need to know the baseline value of each of these metrics. Without a baseline measurement, the impact cannot be demonstrated after a year, and the project will be judged on impressions.

When choosing a solution, it is worth checking whether it provides this data on its own. In Worksmile, it comes from the HR analytics module and from the budget and benefit utilisation reports –⁠ in other words, it is produced as a by-product of everyday work rather than as a separate reporting exercise.

What actually changes: five outcomes, not features

The effects below are what is worth putting into the proposal. They are not system features, but changes in the way the organisation works.

  • Consolidation of the tool stack.
    One platform instead of three or four means a single user database fed from the HR and payroll system, a single procurement process and a single security review. The employee data layer –⁠ organisational structure, employee profiles, manager and administrator panels, API, SSO and mobile apps –⁠ is available free of charge in Worksmile as Core, and the organisation pays only for the modules it selects.

  • Shifting work from HR to where the information is created.
    The employee submits the request, the manager approves it, and HR oversees the process instead of handling it. This is a change in the division of labour, not just in the tool –⁠ we described it in detail in our article on everyday work with an HR platform.

  • Shorter, documented processes at both ends of employment.
    Joining and leaving stop being a series of manual tasks across several systems and become a scenario with a status and an owner. This closes the two most frequently lost elements: equipment and access rights.

  • Visibility of budget utilisation.
    The cost of a benefits package is known down to the last złoty, but its utilisation usually is not. Budget and benefit utilisation reports close this gap and provide a basis for discussing the next budget year.

  • Measurable internal communication.
    Instead of the number of messages sent –⁠ information on who has read them and in which locations a message did not get through. For the board, this is the only way to check whether decisions are actually reaching the organisation.

How do you design an implementation so that it can be accounted for?

Measure the baseline before you start. Three to five metrics are enough. Without this step, every later discussion about impact will be an argument about impressions.

  1. Start with the area where the pain is most acute, not the broadest one. A modular model lets you launch one process, demonstrate the impact and only then expand. It is also a better budget strategy: a smaller amount to start with and a decision to expand based on data.
  2. Appoint a sponsor on the board. The sponsor is the person who is accountable for the project to the board, settles disputes over priorities and –⁠ most importantly –⁠ enforces the change among line managers. A sponsor is needed because the implementation goes beyond the HR department: for a manager to start approving requests in the system, someone has to instruct them to do so, and HR has no line authority over them. Without a sponsor, the project usually stalls at exactly this point.
  3. Schedule a review point. Six and twelve months after launch, on the same metrics you measured at the start.

To be honest: when an implementation will not pay off

Three situations in which the project will not deliver –⁠ it is worth knowing them, because ignoring them costs more than not implementing at all.

  1. A process that does not exist. A system enforces a process, but does not design it. If onboarding has not been designed, the implementation will digitise improvisation. Cost: the full cost of licences and implementation with no change in the organisation.
  2. No adoption among managers. If managers do not approve requests in the system, the work goes back to HR and the organisation ends up with both the old process and a new cost. This is the most common cause of failure and the one least often taken into account in the implementation plan.
  3. Too broad a scope at the start. Launching everything at once blurs accountability and makes it impossible to demonstrate impact, because nobody knows what worked.

It is also worth saying clearly what the platform will not do: it will not replace the HR and payroll system. Payroll calculation, statutory declarations and formal and legal obligations remain on the HR system side, while the platform pulls data from it and exports payroll data to it. (Read about whether an ERP system is enough to manage HR).

Where to start?

If the calculation above came out clearly enough to be worth discussing further, the next step is not a purchase but a measurement. Three to five metrics collected over two weeks give you a proposal based on data from your own organisation, not on someone else’s benchmarks.

In parallel, it is worth looking at your current tool environment from an operational perspective –⁠ that is, how many places HR actually handles and what could be switched off after implementation. Anna Majkowska has described seven questions worth asking yourself before buying another system, from an HR practitioner’s perspective.

In Worksmile, the employee data layer is free of charge, so you can tidy up the organisational structure and employee profiles before deciding on modules –⁠ and launch the first process only where the calculation showed the highest cost of the current state. We described the order of implementation and the division of roles between employees, managers and HR in our article on everyday work with an HR platform.

Frequently asked questions

How do you calculate the return on implementing an HR platform?

By comparing the cost of the current state with the cost of the platform. The cost of the current state consists of four categories: licences and administration of fragmented tools, HR working time spent on repetitive tasks, the cost of first-year turnover and the exposure resulting from unclosed processes. The first three can be calculated on your own data; the fourth is best assessed qualitatively with the legal department.

Which metrics should you measure before and after implementation?

The minimum set is: the total cost of HR tools, the share of the HR team’s time spent on repetitive tasks, the turnaround time of a typical employee request, turnover in the first twelve months of employment and the percentage of employees who read internal communications. The key is to measure the baseline value before the project starts.

Who should sponsor the project on the board?

A person responsible for operations or for HR, but with a mandate that covers line managers. The implementation changes the division of responsibilities between HR, managers and employees, so the sponsor must have influence over all three groups. A project run solely from within the HR department usually stalls at the adoption stage.

What does the platform’s cost model look like?

In Worksmile, the employee data layer, i.e. Core, is available free of charge, and the organisation pays only for the modules it selects. The rate per module decreases as the number of employees grows, and annual billing is more advantageous than monthly. This makes it possible to start with one area and expand the scope based on results.

Does implementation require replacing existing systems?

No. The platform operates one layer above the HR and payroll system and pulls data from it through an integration or API. It does, however, usually replace some of the side tools –⁠ an intranet, a flexible benefits platform or a survey tool –⁠ and it is in this consolidation that the first savings arise.

What are the most common reasons implementations fail?

Three: no designed process before the system is implemented, no adoption among line managers and too broad a scope launched all at once. All three are predictable and can be mitigated at the planning stage.

At what point in the budget year should you start?

It is worth measuring the baseline a quarter before the planned budget proposal –⁠ it takes about two weeks to collect working time data and a few days to compile tool costs. The proposal itself is then based on data from the current year rather than on estimates.

Six takeaways for the board

  1. A proposal for an HR platform wins when it shows the cost of the current state, not the benefit of the target state.

  2. That cost is already in the P&L, spread across four categories: tools, administrative time, turnover and risk exposure.

  3. The CFO, COO and CHRO look at the implementation through three different metrics –⁠ it is worth preparing all three.

  4. Without a baseline measurement, the impact cannot be demonstrated, however good the implementation.

  5. A modular model lets you start with one area, account for it and only then expand the scope.

  6. The three predictable causes of failure are no designed process, no adoption among managers and too broad a start.

Found this article useful? Share it with your team.

Read next

All posts

Ready to simplify HR in your company?

Book a free demo –⁠ we’ll show you how Worksmile works with your processes.

Book a demo