How many hours a week does your HR team lose to manual work? Find out in a free survey (in Polish) →START >>>

Product updatesGrowth

Performance reviews without spreadsheet chaos –⁠ how it works in Worksmile

Performance reviews without spreadsheet chaos – how it works in Worksmile

Periodic performance reviews are regular, planned employee evaluation processes –⁠ and they do not have to be an annual box-ticking exercise involving a spreadsheet sent by email, chasing deadlines, collecting answers by hand and digging up last year’s results in a manager’s private files. A well-designed employee review is part of human resources management, not just an administrative duty: it brings order to how performance, competencies and goal achievement are assessed, makes conversations about development, promotions and training priorities more transparent, and removes the chaos of spreadsheets and emails thanks to an organised system of schedules, participants and forms.

This article is for HR departments, managers and anyone responsible for the employee review process who wants to streamline and structure it. We show which periodic review models exist, how to configure the process, which types of reviews and participants are worth including –⁠ from self-assessment to 360-degree feedback –⁠ why review history matters and how to implement the whole process in Worksmile. What makes the difference is not the review itself, but how it is configured and where its results end up, because that gives the company a better basis for further employee development, HR decisions and deliberately strengthening motivation.

Periodic employee reviews –⁠ where to start?

Before you set a schedule or design forms, one decision is needed: which review model makes sense for your organisation and what the periodic employee review should look like. Reviews can be held at different intervals –⁠ yearly, every six months, quarterly or even monthly –⁠ but periodic reviews are most often planned every 6–⁠12 months to assess results and competencies over a given period; the cycle can also be shortened or extended depending on the organisation. The second decision concerns who takes part in the review: the employee (self-assessment), their line manager, peers, direct reports –⁠ or all of them at once.

A performance review system instead of spreadsheets and emails

When the process grows to cover several teams, spreadsheets and emails mean nobody is sure which version of the file is current, and results from different managers are hard to compare. A performance review system solves this differently: HR defines one cycle, one set of criteria and one schedule for the whole organisation, and a single employee review system also keeps data consistent throughout the process. Review tasks are sent automatically to the selected employees and managers, which saves the HR department real time –⁠ automating periodic reviews can cut this area of work by up to 60%. Results from successive cycles stay in one place –⁠ ready to be compared across teams instead of being scattered across mailboxes.

This is exactly how it works in the Performance and competences module in Worksmile: the administrator configures the cycle once, and the review system itself keeps track of participants, deadlines and response collection statuses. A periodic review system like this lets you follow the data and stages of the process in real time in one place, which supports transparency and order in everyday HR work.

360-degree feedback or a custom model –⁠ how to choose

Not every role and not every team needs full 360-degree feedback. Worksmile lets you choose a review type from 90 to 360 degrees –⁠ the 90, 180, 270 and 360-degree models differ in the scope of information and the number of feedback sources –⁠ or configure a custom model with manually selected components, for example only self-assessment and peer review, without the line manager. The review elements adjust automatically to the selected combination, so you do not have to check manually whether forms and participants match, and review methods can be tailored to each role using different approaches.

For larger teams, one more option matters: by default, each employee is reviewed by all of their peers and direct reports, but the number of reviewers can be limited, and the system can select them at random or let the person being reviewed choose them.

Employee self-assessment and a form tailored to the role

The review form does not have to look the same for the line manager, the self-assessment, peers and direct reports –⁠ in Worksmile each of these roles is configured separately. Such an employee review can combine different methods, for example a points-based rating awards points for specific criteria, while a descriptive assessment adds a broader comment. The key element is the form, which is generated automatically from the competencies assigned to the employee and includes a rating scale and space to write a justification. A descriptive assessment also allows a narrative description of the person’s work and a summary of strengths, areas for improvement and development needs.

Approving results and drawing conclusions from the review cycle

Collecting responses is not the end of the process. Once the cycle closes, the approval stage begins –⁠ based on the collected reviews, the manager sets the final rating for each competency, and the AI Assistant suggests how to draw conclusions from the ratings and the comments that accompany them. For employees without a direct line manager, you can also nominate another person authorised to approve their competencies.

HR or the manager can follow the progress of review collection on an ongoing basis, and after the cycle ends they receive a summary with views of competency density as well as the consistency and potential of the whole team –⁠ instead of manually compiling dozens of forms into a single spreadsheet. These summaries also make HR decisions easier and support team development.

Employee review history as the basis for the annual review meeting

A manager preparing for an annual review meeting opens the employee’s review history from previous periods directly in the system –⁠ instead of searching their mailbox or private notes from several months ago. Preparing for a conversation such as the annual employee review should include analysing results from earlier cycles and feedback from the entire period, because a lack of preparation undermines the credibility of the review. The employee, in turn, has permanent, transparent access to their own results from previous cycles, including in the mobile app –⁠ and can return to them when preparing for a development conversation. This history makes it easier to reflect on one’s own work and to approach the conversation more calmly when the employee feels prepared; without it, and when the employee becomes defensive, the conversation loses its developmental value.

How to implement the periodic review process in Worksmile?

Launching periodic reviews in the Performance and competences module comes down to 3 steps, and the review system itself can be configured to suit the number of people your company employs and the specifics of each role: building a competency library, configuring the cycle (review type, period, participants, schedule –⁠ it is worth setting fair criteria and the purpose of the employee evaluation right away) and launching the cycle. From then on, review tasks appear automatically for the selected people, and once all responses have been collected, the system moves on to the approval and summary stage by itself. This model of periodic employee reviews makes it easier to plan professional development, upskilling and career paths.

Summary

  • A periodic employee review works best when it has a clearly defined frequency, model (90–⁠360° or custom) and participants –⁠ set once for the whole organisation. A review of an employee’s work should also serve an informative function and provide a basis for further development.

  • A performance review system relieves HR of coordinating deadlines by email and manually collecting results from scattered spreadsheets. This is especially important in large companies, where, given the larger scale of processes, it is easier to coordinate the entire employee review system.

  • Configurable forms and the Competency rating field let you adapt the review to the reviewer’s role instead of building a survey from scratch for every cycle.

  • The approval stage with suggestions from the AI Assistant, together with summaries of team density and potential, makes it easier to draw conclusions from the whole cycle.

  • An employee’s review history, available in one place, becomes a real basis for the annual review meeting –⁠ instead of relying on memories of the last quarter –⁠ and also supports planning the next development steps and HR decisions.

Found this article useful? Share it with your team.

Read next

All posts

Ready to simplify HR in your company?

Book a free demo –⁠ we’ll show you how Worksmile works with your processes.

Book a demo