How many hours a week does your HR team lose to manual work? Find out in a free survey (in Polish) →START >>>

GuideBenefits

Job evaluation –⁠ key issues

Job evaluation – key issues

Pay transparency is no longer a topic for “later”. Directive (EU) 2023/970 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 10 May 2023 to strengthen the application of the principle of equal pay requires employers to take a more structured approach to pay, positions and HR data. In practice, this means one thing: job evaluation will become the foundation for reporting, communicating with employees and defending against claims of unequal treatment.

Key takeaways (summary up front)

  • Job evaluation based on 4 criteria –⁠ skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions –⁠ is becoming the key tool for demonstrating equal pay for the same work or work of equal value.

  • Update: the new version of the draft act of 29 April 2026 keeps the main assumptions: a threshold of 100 employees for reporting, a 5% gap threshold that triggers corrective action, and 4 mandatory job evaluation criteria.

  • The draft regulation of the Ministry of Family, Labour and Social Policy (MRPiPS) of 24 April 2026 describes 7 pay gap indicators and 16 sub-indicators, including annual and hourly data, basic pay and variable components.

  • The act is to enter into force 6 months after its publication, so the obligations will realistically apply from Q1 2027 at the earliest –⁠ but pay data for 2026 will already matter.

  • The results of job evaluation must translate into pay grades, pay scales and reliable pay gap reporting. Otherwise, the employer risks fines of PLN 2,000–⁠60,000, litigation and a loss of the sense of fairness across the entire organisation.

2026 legislative update: what the new version of draft act UC127 changes

On 29 April 2026, a new version of draft act UC127 was published on the website of the Government Legislation Centre (RCL), together with a draft regulation of the Ministry of Family, Labour and Social Policy on pay gap indicators. This is not a revolution, but an important clarification of the rules according to which employers will organise job evaluation, reporting and responses to employee requests.

What you should know:

  • The act is to enter into force 6 months after its publication –⁠ not automatically on 7 June 2026. Realistically, the obligations will apply from Q1 2027 at the earliest.

  • Poland is still obliged to transpose EU Directive 2023/970 by 7 June 2026. Postponing the entry into force of the act does not mean the topic goes away; the public sector, including the civil service, must be particularly careful about the direct effect of the directive.

  • The threshold of 100 employees for the pay gap reporting obligation has been kept. Employers with 250+ employees are to report annually, and employers with 100–⁠249 employees every three years.

  • The 4 mandatory job evaluation criteria have been kept: skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions.

  • The 5% pay gap threshold, which triggers corrective action and a joint pay assessment, has been kept.

  • The deadline for responding to each employee request for pay information is 30 days. If the response is incomplete, the employee may request additional information within a further 30 days.

  • Draft act UC127 provides for fines of PLN 2,000–⁠60,000.

  • The monitoring body is to be the Government Plenipotentiary for Equal Treatment, and a Commission for Counteracting Discrimination in Employment is to operate within the State Labour Inspectorate (PIP). The State Labour Inspectorate will retain an important inspection and procedural role.

  • After submitting the report by 31 March, an employer with a gap of ≥5% has until 30 September to take corrective action, until 31 October to verify its effects and until 30 November to carry out a joint pay assessment with employee representatives.

  • The draft regulation of 24 April 2026 sets out mathematical formulas for 7 pay gap indicators, including 16 sub-indicators: annual and hourly, for basic pay and for variable pay components.

You can follow the progress of the work on the Government Legislation Centre website and in materials published by the Ministry of Family, Labour and Social Policy.

What is job evaluation and why is it crucial now?

Job evaluation is a systematic, impersonal process of determining the relative value of individual positions in an organisation, aimed at defining the job structure and the pay policy. What is assessed is not the person but the description of the role: the content of the work, the required competencies, the scope of responsibility, the difficulty of the work and the conditions in which it is performed.

This is an important distinction. A performance review tells you how an employee carries out their duties. Job evaluation tells you what value their position has in the organisational structure. That is why the process is carried out once for each type of role, e.g. “customer service specialist”, rather than separately for every person employed in the same position.

Directive (EU) 2023/970 of 10 May 2023 introduces an obligation to evaluate jobs in order to ensure equal pay for men and women for the same work or work of equal value. Its aim is to strengthen the principle of equal pay for men and women through pay transparency and enforcement mechanisms.

In practice, job evaluation makes it possible to:

  • tidy up job titles and eliminate redundant roles,

  • create a transparent job hierarchy and links to departments,

  • develop a fair pay system and salary ranges,

  • support employee development and career paths,

  • make it easier for HR to set budgets for new hires and plan pay,

  • limit discretion in pay and the risk of pay discrimination.

Transparency in evaluating individual roles makes it easier for employees to understand the pay system. Proper job evaluation also builds trust between employees and the employer, because it shows that pay is based on established criteria rather than on the negotiating power of individuals.

Mandatory job evaluation criteria

Under EU Directive 2023/970, employers are required to evaluate jobs on the basis of four mandatory criteria: skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions. The directive requires job evaluation to be based on objective, gender-neutral criteria such as skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions.

These overarching criteria cannot be omitted. They are the minimum standard for every organisation, but a company may add sub-criteria that reflect its specific nature. The Ministry of Family and the Central Institute for Labour Protection –⁠ National Research Institute (CIOP-PIB) have prepared a guide and an analytical point-factor model with example weights, but the employer may adjust the point weighting to its industry, provided that neutrality and consistency are maintained.

Properly defined job evaluation criteria have a direct impact on the subsequent pay grades, pay scales and the interpretation of the gender pay gap.

Skills –⁠ how to measure them in practice

The “skills” criterion in job evaluation covers the professional, specialist, administrative, operational or technical knowledge and skills needed to perform the work in a given position. It is not just a diploma, but the whole set of requirements needed to do the job effectively.

The model should include, among other things:

  • secondary or higher education,

  • professional experience,

  • courses, certificates and licences,

  • interpersonal skills,

  • digital competencies,

  • knowledge of processes, tools and regulations.

It is not worth limiting yourself to formal qualifications. Work of the same quality is often made possible by practical experience, volunteering, an industry course or long operational practice. This approach reduces the risk of discrimination and better reflects the actual requirements of a given position.

In analytical methods, skills often account for around 30–⁠35% of the total score. A technology company may, however, give them greater weight if its business goals require rare expert competencies.

Effort –⁠ physical, mental and emotional

Effort does not mean physical work alone. A modern job evaluation process should measure physical, mental and emotional effort.

Physical effort includes, for example, lifting, working in an awkward posture, repetitive movements or a high pace of work. Mental effort relates to data analysis, concentration, task complexity and making decisions under time pressure.

Emotional effort is particularly important: contact with clients in crisis, patients, pupils, demanding or aggressive people. Historically, overlooking this dimension led to undervaluing female-dominated occupations such as nurses, teachers or call centre agents, and consequently entrenched pay gaps.

Responsibility –⁠ for people, assets and decisions

Responsibility means the impact a position has on people, resources, information, safety and the company’s results. Typical sub-criteria include:

  • responsibility for a team,

  • financial responsibility,

  • responsibility for a budget and results,

  • responsibility for sensitive data,

  • responsibility for safety,

  • responsibility for decisions affecting the entire organisation.

This criterion must not be reduced to the number of direct reports alone. Experts can also carry high responsibility: an independent engineer, an IT architect, a lawyer, a risk analyst or a compliance specialist. In many analytical models, responsibility carries the highest weight, e.g. 35–⁠40%, because it strongly affects the pay grade.

Working conditions –⁠ the physical and psychological environment

Working conditions include noise, temperature, chemicals, shift work, the risk of accidents, stress, time pressure and unpredictability. A standard office job from 9 to 5 will be assessed differently from work on night shifts, in noise and with a risk of injury.

Services can also be demanding. A cashier is responsible for cash and customer contact, a call centre agent works in noise and under constant time monitoring, and reception often combines serving many people with the need to react quickly. In manufacturing or healthcare companies, working conditions may carry much more weight than the standard 10–⁠15%.

Evaluation methods: summary vs analytical

The basic job evaluation methods fall into two groups: summary (non-analytical) and analytical. Summary methods are faster but less precise. Analytical methods are more time-consuming but deliver more accurate and more objective results.

Job evaluation can be time-consuming and costly, especially when assessments are carried out using analytical methods. This is a real challenge for organisations, but in the context of the directive and pay gap reporting it is hard to avoid.

Summary methods –⁠ when they are too risky

Summary methods involve an overall assessment of positions: ranking, classification or paired comparison without an elaborate points system. The final job hierarchy can be created by comparing positions in pairs and awarding points in each pair.

Their advantages are speed, lower cost and usefulness as a preliminary picture of the hierarchy in a small company. The problem is the lack of clear documentation. It is difficult to demonstrate that the ranking was based on gender-neutral criteria rather than on managers’ intuition.

That is why, in light of Directive 2023/970, summary methods should not be the sole basis of a formal pay system for employers obliged to report.

Analytical methods –⁠ the foundation of compliance with the directive

The analytical point-factor method is the most popular standard in modern Human Resources (HR). Analytical point-factor methods break work down into criteria, sub-criteria and levels, and then assign points. This makes it possible to trace why a given position has a specific value.

Example:

  • skills: 32%,

  • effort: 19%,

  • responsibility: 39%,

  • working conditions: 10%,

  • total: 100%, converted into e.g. 1,000 points.

This approach is auditable. If an employee challenges their pay, the employer can present a detailed description of the requirements, the results for each criterion and a comparison with roles assessed as positions of equal value.

The Ministry of Family points to analytical methods as the practical way forward and provides materials to support employers on the government website. In a medium-sized company, the full job evaluation process usually takes 3–⁠6 months.

The job evaluation process step by step –⁠ from job description to pay grade

The job evaluation process involves several key steps, including setting objectives, appointing an evaluation team, defining the criteria and carrying out the evaluation. In practice, it looks like this:

  1. defining the project objective,

  2. preparing a list of positions,

  3. auditing job descriptions,

  4. choosing the method,

  5. designing criteria, sub-criteria, levels and weights,

  6. pilot,

  7. the evaluation proper,

  8. calibrating the results,

  9. assigning pay grades,

  10. building the pay scale.

The employer should appoint an evaluation team: HR, line managers, and sometimes trade unions and employee representatives. It is also worth adopting rules for the process to avoid errors and ensure consistent criteria.

The job description as the starting point

The foundation is an up-to-date job description. It should include:

  • the job title and department,

  • the purpose of the role,

  • the main tasks,

  • the required qualifications and skills,

  • the scope of responsibility,

  • working conditions and work arrangements,

  • relationships within the organisational structure.

The description must refer to the position, not the person. It should reflect how the work is actually done, not an old scope of duties from a recruitment five years ago. In many companies, an audit and standardisation of job descriptions will be necessary, because role titles are historical, inconsistent or duplicated.

Good descriptions will later serve as a reference point when explaining pay differences, especially if the pay gap exceeds 5%.

Designing the model: criteria, sub-criteria, levels and weights

At this stage, the employer defines at least four criteria, a list of sub-criteria, the number of levels and qualitative descriptions. It then assigns percentage weights that add up to 100% and distributes points between the criteria according to their importance for your organisation.

Level descriptions should be specific. Instead of “extensive experience”, it is better to write: “at least 5 years’ experience in independently managing projects with a budget above X”. This makes it easier for different people to award points consistently.

Positions in a company can be classified on the basis of predefined classes or categories with a specified description of requirements. It is important that the model reflects your organisation’s real needs and complies with the principle of equal pay.

Testing and the evaluation proper

Before full implementation, it is worth running a pilot on 10–⁠20 roles from different departments. The test shows whether the model distinguishes well between levels of job difficulty, whether most positions avoid falling into a single band, and whether the descriptions are understandable.

The proper process should follow a single procedure:

  • analysis of the description,

  • team discussion,

  • awarding points for each sub-criterion,

  • justification,

  • verification,

  • approval.

Documentation is key. The evaluation sheet or HR system should show how many points each position received for each criterion and why. Without this, it will be difficult to defend decisions before the State Labour Inspectorate, an employee or a court.

From job evaluation to pay scales and pay gap reporting

Scoring alone is not enough. Job evaluation makes it possible to create a transparent job hierarchy and links to departments, but only translating points into grades and salary ranges creates a practical pay system.

The objective requirements of a given position make it possible to develop fair salary ranges. Positions with a similar number of points form groups of work of equal value, and each group is assigned a pay grade.

Pay grades and work of equal value

Grades are created using point bands, e.g.:

  • G1: 100–⁠200 points,

  • G2: 201–⁠300 points,

  • G3: 301–⁠450 points,

  • G4: 451–⁠600 points.

Positions in one grade are treated as work of equal value. This means that pay differences between women and men in the same grade must be justified by objective criteria: experience, performance, length of service, location, qualifications or specific duties.

The number of grades depends on the size of the organisation. In a company of 100–⁠250 people, 6–⁠8 grades are usually enough. A large group of companies may need separate managerial and expert tracks.

Pay scales and salary ranges in each grade

Once the grades have been defined, the company builds pay scales. This is a table with min–⁠mid–⁠max ranges for each grade, sometimes broken down by location, job family or career path.

The logic is simple:

  • minimum: a person new to the role,

  • midpoint: full independence,

  • maximum: expert level or readiness for promotion.

Pay can be differentiated within a single grade, but this must be described in the pay policy. Market data is helpful, but it cannot replace the internal logic of the job evaluation.

A transparent pay scale makes it easier to respond to an employee’s request. HR can show the grade of their position, the rules for positioning within the range and a comparison with employees doing the same work or work of equal value.

The directive introduces a pay gap reporting obligation for employers with at least 100 employees. Companies with 250+ employees report annually, and companies with 100–⁠249 employees every three years. Under the Polish draft act, companies with 150+ employees will submit their first report by 7 June 2027, and companies with 100–⁠149 employees only by 7 June 2031 –⁠ although the exact deadlines depend on the final date on which the act is published.

Job evaluation aims to increase pay transparency and reduce the pay gap between men and women, which is a key objective of the directive. Without job evaluation and pay grades, it is impossible to reliably compare work of equal value.

The MRPiPS regulation provides for calculating the indicators using a uniform formula: the difference between men’s and women’s pay divided by men’s pay × 100%. The data is to include, among other things, gross annual pay, gross hourly pay, basic pay and variable components such as bonuses, overtime and allowances.

Reliable job evaluation makes it possible to distinguish natural differences resulting from grade, length of service, competencies or performance from unjustified discrepancies that need to be corrected.

Job evaluation is not just an HR project. It is part of managing legal risk once the pay transparency act enters into force.

The main risks are:

  • fines of PLN 2,000–⁠60,000,

  • compensation for pay discrimination,

  • a reversed burden of proof,

  • collective and individual disputes,

  • possible exclusion from public procurement in the event of an unjustified gap of >5%,

  • loss of employee trust.

Directive 2023/970 introduces a reversed burden of proof in pay discrimination cases, which means that the employer must prove that there was no discrimination if it has not fulfilled its transparency obligations. The lack of a structured job evaluation process will make such a defence much more difficult.

Job evaluation supports compliance with European pay transparency rules. One of the main advantages of job evaluation is the creation of a fair pay system that prevents pay discrimination by ensuring equal pay for work of equal value.

Key dates: 2026, the act’s entry into force and the first report

The most important dates:

  • 10 May 2023 –⁠ adoption of Directive (EU) 2023/970;

  • 24 April 2026 –⁠ MRPiPS draft regulation on pay gap indicators;

  • 29 April 2026 –⁠ new version of draft act UC127;

  • 7 June 2026 –⁠ deadline for transposing Directive 2023/970;

  • Q1 2027 –⁠ the realistic earliest start of the obligations, if the act is published late enough;

  • 7 June 2027 –⁠ the deadline for the first report under the directive for the largest employers, subject to the final national legislation.

After the report has been submitted by 31 March of the following year, the draft provides for: corrective action by 30 September, verification of its effects by 31 October, and a joint pay assessment with employee representatives by 30 November.

That is why companies with 100+ employees should treat 2026 as a time of intensive preparation: auditing job descriptions, choosing a method, evaluating jobs, defining pay grades, carrying out a preliminary gap analysis and testing reports.

Worksmile supports you in implementing pay transparency

Our platform supports analytical point-factor job evaluation based on the 4 mandatory criteria, employee categories, an information request form (with full tracking of 30-day deadlines), a pay gap dashboard covering all 7 indicators, and annual notices to employees.

We also prepare clients for agreements with trade unions and support them in choosing a methodology. What is more, if any changes are made during further legislative work, we will adapt our solution to the final version of the regulations, to give our clients complete peace of mind and maximum support in this process.

SEE PAY TRANSPARENCY IN WORKSMILE >

Frequently asked questions

Do small companies (fewer than 100 employees) also have to carry out job evaluation?

Formal pay gap reporting under draft act UC127 applies to employers with at least 100 employees. However, the principle of equal pay for work of equal value applies to all employers under the Labour Code (Kodeks pracy) and EU law.

A smaller company can also become a party to a pay discrimination dispute. A simplified analytical job evaluation can therefore help with recruitment, pay planning and defending against claims of unequal treatment.

Can the job evaluation model be changed after it has been implemented?

Yes. The model is not set in stone. However, changes need to be documented, justified on business grounds and communicated to employees.

A good standard is to review the criteria, weights and level descriptions every 2–⁠3 years or after a major change in the organisational structure, e.g. a merger, entry into a new market or a change in the business model. Historical consistency is also important, so that results can be compared year on year.

How should bonuses and allowances be treated in job evaluation and pay gap reporting?

Job evaluation focuses on the requirements of the work, not on the bonus a particular person received. However, the results of the evaluation are later needed to check that variable components are not awarded in a discriminatory way.

The MRPiPS regulation requires basic pay and variable components to be reported separately –⁠ on an annual and hourly basis. That is why bonus rules should be transparent and linked to performance and business objectives, not to gender, availability after hours or family status.

Can you rely solely on the free MRPiPS tool?

You can treat it as a starting point, especially in SMEs. The tool is consistent with the philosophy of the directive and shows how the analytical point-factor approach works.

However, it does not solve everything for the employer. The company must itself define the sub-criteria, level descriptions, weights and the way decisions are documented. Larger organisations often develop the ministry’s model further or implement HR tools that support job evaluation, reporting and communication with employees.

How should you prepare communication to employees about job evaluation?

First, explain the purpose: equal treatment, transparency and legal compliance. Then describe the stages of the process, the roles of the evaluation team, the timeline and the difference between evaluating a position and assessing an employee.

It is worth preparing a Q&A on the intranet, messages for managers and simple guidance on what pay grades and salary ranges mean. Draft act UC127 also requires employees to be informed every year of their right to request pay information, so communication cannot be a one-off exercise. Worksmile can help with this –⁠ with the communication module you can keep employees up to date with pay transparency announcements, create groups and run surveys on their level of knowledge. At the same time, you can collect materials that will serve employees as a knowledge base and make them available to everyone in one place.

If you want to make good use of the time until 2027, start by auditing your job descriptions and piloting job evaluation. It is the simplest way to build a fair pay system, prepare data for reporting and avoid costly last-minute corrections.

Found this article useful? Share it with your team.

Read next

All posts

Ready to simplify HR in your company?

Book a free demo –⁠ we’ll show you how Worksmile works with your processes.

Book a demo